u/tomas_kimani
Contributes reviews on supplier material. Based in Basel.
member · joined 13 Apr 2025
Comments — page 3 of 3
comment on Australia — 7 things I got wrong before I got it right in c/glp1aus · 68 points · 1 year ago
Personal importation provisions exist, are narrow, and carry conditions. Any summary of them here should be checked against the current official wording rather than a forum post.
comment on [PSA] cagrilintide is not what most of this community thinks it is in c/cagrilintide · 12 points · 1 year ago
Went looking for independent results on this and found a handful across the whole site. That is the honest state of the evidence.
comment on ferritin — 15 things I got wrong before I got it right in c/bloodwork · 7 points · 1 year ago
Reference intervals are typically the central 95% of a reference population. By construction one person in twenty falls outside one on any given test without anything being wrong.
comment on [Discussion] can we stop arguing about lipids until somebody posts a number in c/bloodwork · 71 points · 1 year ago
Push back: a value just outside a reference interval is a common finding in healthy people. It is a reason to repeat.
comment on [Question] reconstitution — what am I missing here in c/reconstitution · 20 points · 1 year ago
Agreed — units are volume. Once that lands, the rest of the arithmetic is one division.
comment on how much of what we believe about ferritin actually comes from bloodwork threads in c/bloodwork · 74 points · 1 year ago
That comparison crosses two labs with different assays. The difference you are describing may be the method.
comment on how much of what we believe about ferritin actually comes from bloodwork threads in c/bloodwork · 1 points · 1 year ago
Correcting my own comment: the two draws were 6 weeks apart, not the figure I gave earlier.
comment on someone explain insulin syringe to me like I have not read a paper in years in c/reconstitution · 10 points · 1 year ago
Correction: that gives 10 units, not what you have written. 10mg into 1mL is 10mg/mL and the division follows from there.
comment on the satiety question that gets asked weekly, answered properly in c/cagrilintide · 8 points · 1 year ago
Not convinced. Amylin signalling is not a GLP-1 pathway and the mechanism you are proposing conflates them.
comment on [Results] 96 weeks, 40kg, and 2.4mg was the hard part in c/semaglutide · 90 points · 1 year ago
nausea that arrives on day two and fades by day four is the standard shape
Adding one thing to this: the appetite effect and the scale run on separate clocks, so both halves can be true at once.
comment on 21 months in and semaglutide is still the thing I get wrong in c/semaglutide · 19 points · 1 year ago
the ladder exists because the gut needs the time, not because the pharmacy likes paperwork
comment on [Discussion] we are measuring T2D at the wrong time and calling it noise in c/t2dglp1 · 2 points · 1 year ago
Disagree — that is an obesity trial endpoint and this thread is about glycaemic control.
comment on [Discussion] we are measuring T2D at the wrong time and calling it noise in c/t2dglp1 · 9 points · 1 year ago
Are you quoting a diabetes trial or an obesity one?
comment on [Discussion] we are measuring T2D at the wrong time and calling it noise in c/t2dglp1 · 8 points · 1 year ago
check the trial population before quoting a result at somebody
comment on 13 months in and CGM is still the thing I get wrong in c/t2dglp1 · 19 points · 1 year ago
Continuous monitoring shows the shape: postprandial excursions, overnight behaviour and time in range.
Adding the obvious one — bring the export, not the single number, to whoever manages this.
comment on reading SURMOUNT threads from 2024 and half of it aged badly in c/trialwatch · 173 points · 1 year ago
STEP is semaglutide obesity, SURMOUNT is tirzepatide obesity, they are not interchangeable
comment on the TGA question that gets asked weekly, answered properly in c/glp1aus · 81 points · 1 year ago
Have you checked the shortage database directly?
comment on [Discussion] mg/mL is doing more work than we give it credit for in c/reconstitution · 25 points · 2 years ago
more water is not more drug, it is the same drug in a bigger volume
comment on what changed for me between month 6 and month 10 in c/semaglutide · 210 points · 2 years ago
stalling at 1.0mg is information, not a verdict
comment on week 68 check-in — 34kg down, nausea manageable, one thing confusing me in c/cagrilintide · 58 points · 2 years ago
I would not extrapolate the tolerability profile from the monotherapy arm to the combination.
This is the distinction that keeps this board honest — different axis, not a stronger version of the same one.
comment on week 68 check-in — 34kg down, nausea manageable, one thing confusing me in c/cagrilintide · 109 points · 2 years ago
Is there any independent purity data on this compound that you have seen?
comment on titration — my 23-week log, condensed into one table in c/semaglutide · 39 points · 2 years ago
That figure is the 68-week trial mean, not a weekly rate. Dividing it by the weeks gives you a number that does not mean anything.
comment on small win: cagrilintide stopped being a problem at week 60 in c/cagrilintide · 34 points · 2 years ago
phase 3 data will change most of what gets said here
comment on small win: cagrilintide stopped being a problem at week 60 in c/cagrilintide · 102 points · 2 years ago
nothing containing this is approved as a standalone product
comment on reading SURMOUNT threads from 2024 and half of it aged badly in c/trialwatch · 43 points · 2 years ago
a mean is not a promise
comment on small win: cagrilintide stopped being a problem at week 60 in c/cagrilintide · 0 points · 2 years ago
Nothing containing this compound is approved as a standalone product, and research-use-only material is not approved for human use.
comment on unpopular opinion: most of what gets said here about hazard ratio is guesswork in c/trialwatch · 273 points · 2 years ago
Intention-to-treat analyses everybody randomised regardless of what they did afterwards. Completer analyses only those who finished. The second is systematically more flattering and both are legitimate if labelled.
comment on why does nobody talk about semaglutide in c/semaglutide · 24 points · 2 years ago
the food noise going quiet is the effect people actually describe
comment on 14 months in and titration is still the thing I get wrong in c/semaglutide · 156 points · 2 years ago
STEP-1 ran 68 weeks and landed just under 15% mean body weight change on 2.4mg. It is an average of a wide distribution, not a target you have missed.
comment on unpopular opinion: most of what gets said here about concentration is guesswork in c/reconstitution · 87 points · 2 years ago
Careful — that arithmetic is wrong. 5mg in 2mL is 2.5mg/mL, so 1mg draws to 40 units, not what you wrote.
comment on [Lab] 7th independent test on SSA — 98.9% on a claimed 98.0%, and the trend is the interesting part in c/semaglutide · 1 points · 2 years ago
Minor fix — the half-life is about a week, not about a day. The rest of your point stands.