u/rt_shift_reggie
Retention time shifted 0.4 min and nobody wants to talk about it.
member · joined 19 Mar 2025
Comments — page 2 of 3
comment on [Results] 17 weeks, 6kg, and cagrilintide was the hard part in c/cagrilintide · 77 points · 6 months ago
That is preclinical work and the thread is treating it as a human finding.
comment on [Discussion] we are measuring first time at the wrong time and calling it noise in c/newbiequestions · 22 points · 6 months ago
What does the wiki page on this say — genuinely asking, not deflecting?
comment on [Question] the UK — has anyone got a straight answer on reimbursement in c/glp1eu · 9 points · 7 months ago
Correcting myself upthread: the criterion I quoted was updated for this year.
comment on [Question] the UK — has anyone got a straight answer on reimbursement in c/glp1eu · 21 points · 7 months ago
Supply notices are issued nationally. A notice in one member state does not imply availability problems in another, even for the same product.
comment on tried week one for 12 weeks. here is what happened. in c/newbiequestions · 106 points · 7 months ago
The five things that would have saved me the most time in month one.
One: the first month is a tolerance check, not a results phase. Two: appetite usually changes before the scale does, so watch that instead. Three: write the concentration and the date on the vial the moment you reconstitute anything. Four: the loud posts are not the middle of the distribution. Five: nobody here — including whoever answers most confidently — is your clinician.
None of that is advice about what to take. It is the shape of the first few weeks, which is what I actually wanted and could not find.
comment on someone explain first time to me like I have not read a paper in years in c/newbiequestions · 63 points · 7 months ago
Nothing on this board is medical advice, and the people answering you — including me — are members with spreadsheets rather than clinicians.
comment on SURPASS — 6 things I got wrong before I got it right in c/trialwatch · 20 points · 8 months ago
a press release is not a publication
comment on [Discussion] first time is doing more work than we give it credit for in c/newbiequestions · 3 points · 8 months ago
Concentration is mass over volume, and a U-100 syringe reads 100 units per millilitre.
britta_nakamura has explained this better than the wiki does, which is saying something.
comment on SURPASS — 6 things I got wrong before I got it right in c/trialwatch · 1 points · 8 months ago
Small fix — that was the cardiovascular outcomes trial, so weight was a secondary endpoint and the population was different.
comment on SURPASS — 6 things I got wrong before I got it right in c/trialwatch · 1 points · 8 months ago
How long was the randomised phase before any extension?
comment on SURPASS — 6 things I got wrong before I got it right in c/trialwatch · 55 points · 8 months ago
STEP is semaglutide obesity, SURMOUNT is tirzepatide obesity, they are not interchangeable
comment on [PSA] prescription is not what most of this community thinks it is in c/glp1eu · 166 points · 8 months ago
Marketing authorisation is granted centrally for these products; reimbursement, pricing and prescribing criteria are national competences. Those are decided by different bodies with different processes.
comment on private prescription — 20 things I got wrong before I got it right in c/glp1uk · 25 points · 8 months ago
Same. My ICB threshold was different from the neighbouring one and nobody could tell me why.
comment on [Discussion] we are measuring 503B at the wrong time and calling it noise in c/compounding · 1 points · 11 months ago
shortage status changes and the whole arrangement changes with it
comment on [Question] MHRA — what am I missing here in c/glp1uk · 24 points · 1 year ago
That is Scotland’s arrangement and the post is asking about England.
comment on [Question] MHRA — what am I missing here in c/glp1uk · 7 points · 1 year ago
NHS pathway or private prescription?
comment on private prescription — 23 things I got wrong before I got it right in c/glp1uk · 432 points · 1 year ago
The two routes, described separately, because mixing them is where most of the confusion here starts.
The NHS route in England runs through specialist weight management services commissioned by your ICB. Criteria, waiting times and what happens at discharge are all local decisions, which is why a confident answer from somebody in a different area may be wrong for you.
The private route is an independent transaction: a consultation, a prescription and a pharmacy price. It does not affect your position on any NHS list and it is not a shortcut through one. Both are legitimate; they are simply not the same pathway and they do not connect.
comment on [Results] 2 weeks on 7.5mg, full numbers, ask me anything boring in c/cagrilintide · 6 points · 1 year ago
That result is preclinical. Worth flagging, since the thread has been reading it as human data.
comment on [Question] normal — what am I missing here in c/newbiequestions · 8 points · 1 year ago
Push back on the advice above: nobody here can tell a member what dose to take, however confidently it is phrased.
Slight disagreement with this bit only, because a beginner reading it might take it as a plan rather than a description.
comment on genuine question about telehealth that I am slightly embarrassed to ask in c/compounding · 8 points · 1 year ago
do not assume the concentration matches the branded product
comment on 13 months in and basics are still the thing I get wrong in c/newbiequestions · 30 points · 1 year ago
week two with nothing happening is normal
comment on is it normal to get food noise at week 47 in c/cagrilintide · 10 points · 1 year ago
do not assume the dosing intuitions from the GLP-1 boards transfer
comment on how much of what we believe about endpoint actually comes from STEP threads in c/trialwatch · 2 points · 1 year ago
A confidence interval is the range of effects compatible with the data.
Adding the check nobody runs — the registered protocol is public and takes two minutes to compare.
comment on switched from 0.5mg to 2.4mg and early fullness got better, not worse in c/newbiequestions · 0 points · 1 year ago
Appetite change and weight change are different measurements on different timescales.
Adding the one habit worth starting today: write the concentration on the vial.
comment on [PSA] compounding is not what most of this community thinks it is in c/compounding · 4 points · 1 year ago
What is the beyond-use date and what is it based on?
comment on what changed for me between month 7 and month 12 in c/newbiequestions · 50 points · 1 year ago
Right, and writing the concentration on the vial is the single best habit anyone here can start with.
comment on [Question] how do you actually verify SURPASS in c/trialwatch · 40 points · 1 year ago
Agreed on comparators. "Superior" means nothing until you know superior to what and at what dose.
comment on how much of what we believe about EMA actually comes from pharmacy threads in c/glp1eu · 29 points · 1 year ago
EU-wide advice is almost always wrong somewhere
Agreed — and normalising pack size before comparing prices is the fix for half these threads.
comment on three years of week one threads, summarised so you do not have to read them in c/newbiequestions · 25 points · 1 year ago
The vocabulary, once, since half the questions here are really vocabulary questions.
Titration is stepping the dose up slowly for tolerance. Reconstitution is adding water to a freeze-dried powder. Bacteriostatic water contains a preservative; sterile water does not. COA is a certificate of analysis — a lab document about one batch. Area percent is a purity measure from that document, and it is not the amount of peptide in the vial. Units are a volume on an insulin syringe, not a dose.
That is most of the jargon on this site. The wiki has the longer version of each and it is linked in the sidebar.
comment on [Discussion] TRIUMPH is doing more work than we give it credit for in c/trialwatch · 66 points · 1 year ago
phase 2 finds a dose, phase 3 measures the effect
comment on [Discussion] we are measuring private prescription at the wrong time and calling it noise in c/glp1uk · 279 points · 1 year ago
The two routes, described separately, because mixing them is where most of the confusion here starts.
The NHS route in England runs through specialist weight management services commissioned by your ICB. Criteria, waiting times and what happens at discharge are all local decisions, which is why a confident answer from somebody in a different area may be wrong for you.
The private route is an independent transaction: a consultation, a prescription and a pharmacy price. It does not affect your position on any NHS list and it is not a shortcut through one. Both are legitimate; they are simply not the same pathway and they do not connect.
comment on [Discussion] we are measuring private prescription at the wrong time and calling it noise in c/glp1uk · 9 points · 1 year ago
the ICB decides the threshold and they are not the same across England
comment on [Results] 16 weeks, 5kg, and basics were the hard part in c/newbiequestions · 44 points · 1 year ago
What week are you in?
comment on genuine question about UK that I am slightly embarrassed to ask in c/glp1uk · 882 points · 1 year ago
A private prescription is an independent route: it does not affect NHS list position, and it is not a step in the same pathway.
comment on help me understand telehealth, I have read the wiki twice in c/compounding · 1 points · 1 year ago
Concentration on the compounded vial was different from what I had been using and I nearly did the arithmetic on autopilot.
comment on help me understand telehealth, I have read the wiki twice in c/compounding · 1 points · 1 year ago
Is the compound still on the shortage list where you are?
comment on three years of reimbursement threads, summarised so you do not have to read them in c/glp1eu · 32 points · 2 years ago
pack sizes differ, so per-month comparisons need care
comment on small win: what is stopped being a problem at week 72 in c/newbiequestions · 107 points · 2 years ago
What is the actual question underneath the question? Happy to answer both.
comment on pharmacy — 20 things I got wrong before I got it right in c/glp1eu · 8 points · 2 years ago
A supply notice in one member state made the front page here and had no effect at all where I am.
comment on the pricing thing finally clicked for me and I want to write it down in c/glp1uk · 10 points · 2 years ago
NHS pathway or private prescription?